World travel is an amazing privilege – but how will the impact come down?

16 May 2016

Plane in flight
Photo: Kuster & Wildhaber

Let’s be practical for a moment about the most likely way that air travel emissions will be brought into line in a sustainable future. Put aside the sometimes-ideological debate about what should be and think about the most likely circumstances that will be.

We know that air travel is one of the knottiest problems when it comes to global emissions. It’s currently the fastest growing source of emissions, arising from 3 billion flights per year to contribute around 5 per cent of total emissions. 

We also know that, as a global society, we value travel. Exposure to the beauty of the world, and to other races and cultures, generally promotes a healthier attitude to all of those things. And in any case, people want it. No government has even considered standing on a platform of locking it down.

Logically, two things are going to happen. One, technical innovation is going to continue to reduce the environmental cost of flights taken. Maybe a Tesla-style disruptive innovation will be the next big commercial prize. Two, governments will put in place a ceiling for how high the volume of flights, or more likely the emissions from those flights, can go. It will be as high as they dare make it. Even so, it will push prices up which will reduce demand to match those limits.

If the industry fails to deliver on its 2020 promise, that will throw the Paris climate ambitions out

Assuming we don’t hurtle over the edge into the abyss in the mean time, those things will happen. Simply because they have to, we will find a way.

Here’s the part some people will hate. First, the self-denying abstinence of the small number of environmentalists who feel that strongly about it will make more or less zero contribution to how we get there. Nothing wrong with choosing not to fly as a personal statement, or as an act of conscience. But in terms of changing aggregate behaviour, zip.

Second, the fact that price will become a key factor will mean, yes, that a small number of people with lots of money will continue to fly lots, while significant numbers of others will be priced out, at least of being able to fly as often as they might otherwise have. I know some think it should be down to quotas and personal carbon budgets. By all means campaign for it. But history and pragmatism rather suggests that it’s going to be hard enough to get the simple, slightly unfair but effective, version. Just don’t let the perfect become the enemy of the good.

For the avoidance of doubt, I love to travel. I do not feel guilt when I fly. We have to bring down the aggregate impact of human travel, and that’s why pressure has to be brought to bear where the levers for change actually are to be found. But travel is a beautiful thing.

As an aside, there’s nothing more shallow and time-wasting than slating those people who fly in order to further the cause of trying to solve climate change. Whether it’s Al Gore going to make presentations to groups of key decision makers, or national representatives meeting to negotiate climate change policy. Out of the 1.1bn flights per year, don’t we think we’d really want a tiny fraction of them to be to help people who are trying to solve the problem? I mean, really?

So what are the prospects for progress? Is there a technical breakthrough on the cards? Robust action on overall flight numbers?

When it comes to technical breakthroughs, we are behind where we are on motor vehicles, for sure. Although the standard vehicle on the road remains polluting, we are seeing evidence of real forward momentum there. 

With flying, the technical problems have not yet been solved. It looks pretty much the way the car industry did 15 years ago, with the established companies making incremental steps and wringing their hands about how difficult it is.

The main problem with flights is down to weight. Planes have to carry enough fuel to get them across the world, and so to move all that at speed takes a lot of energy. Increasing efficiency can help, but a lot of the easy wins have already been made. Modern planes are a lot lighter than they used to be, with more energy-efficient engines.

Indeed, some point out that with the most up to date planes air travel is now less damaging to the environment than driving a car. Which is all well and good, but that is still 3 billion international road trips we’re talking about.

The expectation is that small improvements in efficiency can continue to be made, but these will be more than offset by increases in demand driving higher volumes. At least, unless policy intervenes.

What about bolder step changes? The obvious point of focus is for alternative fuels. A number of different airlines are experimenting with different flavours of biofuels – air fuel derived from plant sources. The various trials and studies will continue, and there may well be something waiting to emerge from that body of work that will show promise.

At the moment, biofuels look problematic for a number of reasons. One is down to certain inherent challenges with the nature of the fuel. Biofuels tend to freeze at standard airliner cruising temperatures, for instance. That’s one reason why test flights to date have generally used blends of biofuel mixed in with conventional fuel.

Another is the question about the sheer quantity of land that would need to be put over to crops for biofuels if it was to become the primary energy source for the whole aviation industry. And whether that use of land would be compatible with the challenge of feeding nine billion people, which seems to be where the world is headed (a whole other discussion).

That’s simply to outline the scale of the challenges to be overcome, not to suggest that these are problems that could never be solved. Again, 15 years ago it seemed less than certain that the challenges of producing even a hybrid vehicle could be practically overcome, let alone a fully electric vehicle that was actually a desirable car to own.

Solar Impulse
The Solar Impulse - great experiment, but practically speaking the airborne equivalent of a milk float

On the more radical end there has been a trial of a solar-powered flight. This has captured attention and imagination of some, but it is a long way away from being a contender. The Solar Impulse plane had to leave out anything that added weight, including pressurised and climate controlled cabins. A fully laden 737 weighs 30 times more. And the Solar Impulse flies at around 56mph. About a tenth of the speed of a standard flight.

It doesn’t mean there isn’t a potential breakthrough innovation in the wings. You don’t always see such innovations coming. New products make the biggest impact when they get a ‘big reveal’ moment, so secrecy is maintained up until that point. The thing we do know is that the industry will be under policy pressure over coming years, and this will create the potential conditions and incentive for some disruptive innovation to attract investment.

The aviation industry has committed itself to achieve carbon neutral growth from 2020. That is the scale of its immediate challenge. The UN aviation body is working on a draft for a global offsetting mechanism to help deliver this.

However, the negotiations are difficult. The US wants the focus to be on airline growth, not on standard current emissions. That would favour its own carriers, which are generally mature, at the expense of rapidly growing companies such as Turkish Airways.

In any case, this being the UN, its draft only covers international air flights. Domestic flights are not covered, since that’s down to national policy to deal with. Europe includes aviation in its emissions trading scheme. But the US, which accounts for two-thirds of domestic aviation emissions, has no firm plans. When China launches its national carbon market in 2017, it expects to include air flights, and this will increase the pressure on the US to play its part.

Overall, that means that the conditions are starting to come about within which change is going to become inevitable, and technology breakthroughs will promise considerable rewards.

The clock is ticking. If the industry fails to deliver on its 2020 promise, that will throw the Paris climate ambitions out, and that would make it much more likely that governments will begin to introduce more intrusive regional regimes that is exactly what the airlines are trying to avoid.