The new standard for business will be better than ‘don’t be evil’

28 April 2016

Demon CEO

Let’s generalise for a moment. People mostly think bankers are pretty evil. Still. A smaller but growing number think the same about fossil fuel company bosses. And people got so used to thinking it about the big tobacco bosses that it’s almost no longer a thing.

We focus on business here, so we won’t go into the politicians and journalists. But it’s the same process.

It’s comforting to group such people together, decide that they’re all greedy, reckless or stupid, and demonise them to the sounds of applause far and wide from other “people like us”.

But it doesn’t make sense. Really. Practically.

What are the odds that specific industry sectors would uniquely and universally attract the lowest forms of vermin that the human species can produce?

No, it isn’t about the people. It’s about the system. It’s about the fact that we tend to follow incentives, and we’ve created a system that makes a virtue out of that being the best process.

Here's my prediction: In the future, we will no longer celebrate people who succeed selfishly

When Google first framed the values statement “don’t be evil” during its IPO in 2004 it got a lot of attention. It seemed very progressive at the time, underlining the point that the brave new tech businesses of the future were different to what had gone before.

Of course, it also made a rod for the company’s back. Every time it has been faced with a dilemma or a difficult choice, someone has been able to throw that statement back in its face.

But the more interesting part is this. Actually, it really wasn’t a departure at all from what had gone before. When Milton Friedman and others said that the social responsibility of business was to focus on making as much profit as possible, whilst obeying the law – that last clause was the recognition that you should stay within the rules of the game. Friedman never argued that you should be evil in the cause of maximising profit, only that it was someone else’s job to set the parameters.

So how did Google end up falling foul of society over the tax question? Because it was following fairly mainstream incentives to minimise costs, and this was the accepted norm within such global businesses. They broke no laws. But societal attitudes change over time, and the expectations on business change just as quickly.

The point is this. That standard for business in recent decades has been that shareholders expect an amoral approach. Not immoral. Not doing evil. Amoral. It’s not your job to judge. You follow the incentives of your industry within the rules of the game.

Most business leaders do this. In every sector of business. Generally, it works out ok for them. They don’t end up vilified.

But certain sectors have inbuilt perverse incentives, or they’ve developed these over time.

Milton Friedman
Milton Friedman

In the banking sector, you can make more money with products too complicated for your customers to understand. You could apparently make more money with higher risk products, because safe boring products have very low margins.

In the fossil fuel sector, you make money by operating a hugely expensive infrastructure to extract resources from the ground and distribute them efficiently around the world. It’s understood that the rules of the game mean this should be done safely. After the Exxon Valdez incident, Exxon invested in safety systems to become the leader in the industry. But there are no incentives built into the model to accelerate society’s understanding of, and action on, the implications of climate change.

The tobacco logic is even easier. The more people smoking cigarettes, the more profit you make. The more people start smoking, the better you cope with the fact that quite a few of your customers die early. Those are the marketplace incentives, pure and simple. You don’t have to look them in the face callously for them still to be a powerful force in your decision-making.

In the face of these industry-based incentives, being amoral isn’t enough. And all that really highlights is that being amoral in all industries isn’t enough. Because you never know where perverse incentives are going to arise.

In plain language, you never know where doing your lawful business may end up unnecessarily hurting people or harming the environment we depend upon for survival.

‘Amoral’ says that so long as you don’t specifically commission obviously bad things to happen, then it’s ok.

And it’s not as though the people we put in to run these businesses are universally callous towards the wider moral implications. Their amoral attitude is generally rigorously enforced upon them.

There is always a choice. It’s why we put human beings in charge rather than algorithms

When Andrew Witty at GlaxoSmithKline challenged the current pricing model of the pharmaceutical industry, which has such negative consequences on poorer countries, a number of influential shareholders started agitating for him to be removed. It’s actually a very difficult act of leadership to turn around to those people to say “we’re not going to do this highly profitable thing because of the moral implications.” Or even “doing it differently will be more moral and may be as profitable, but we can’t prove it and we’re taking a risk.”

The good news is that although there’s a long way to go, change is in the air.

We’re seeing enough new businesses that are challenging old business models that it’s now starting to feel like a growing movement.

Look at who’s being talked about as the companies of the future, they are the ones designing businesses to go to the heart of a problem, rather than peddle just one solution. For instance, if you define yourself as a sustainable energy company, then you will always go in the direction of the best solution available to you that can work in the marketplace. If you define yourself as an oil company, then you fight to the death against anything and everything that says oil is not the best answer.

Here’s my prediction. In the future, we will no longer celebrate people who succeed selfishly.

For the new breed of sustainability-minded business executives, the key thing is to understand that business now has a moral dimension. This isn’t yet universally accepted. But the industries that have destroyed the most value in recent decades did so because they amorally followed their incentives regardless of any misgivings because they felt they had no choice.

But there is always a choice. It’s why we put human beings in charge rather than algorithms.

The new exam question for business execs everywhere. How do we create wealth by making the world better and more sustainable? Believe it or not, there is an answer to that question for every business sector.

This isn’t the rearguard action of hippies wearing suits and ties. It’s about the legitimate future of successful business.