Is it a good or bad thing if the media companies shape the world with their content?
10 June 2016
Something like fifteen years ago, I was speaking on a panel that included the then editor of the Sunday Times. In the course of the discussion, he bluntly stated that corporate social responsibility was something that didn’t apply to the editorial functions of the media, just the business side where they could make decisions like buying recycled paper.
This was around the same time when one of the trashiest tabloid newspapers in Britain had run a series of ‘upskirt photos’ of celebrities on its front page. I suppose that was an argument that said that CSR didn’t apply to editorial functions, but certainly not one to suggest that it shouldn’t.
At least we’ve moved on. If a paper ran such a series now, it would be condemned for engaging in assault (although I never understood why it wasn’t at the time). Overall, we have been much more willing to accept that the media are not just ‘mirrors’ – reflecting us back as we really are – but ‘movers’ – shaping attitudes by the things that they choose to show.
At the recent Media CSR Forum event, we looked at a number of aspects of this. It can definitely be a force for good. For instance, it was pointed out that the whole concept of having a “designated driver” on a night out came from the deliberate introduction of the concept into a number of popular shows, which turned it into a common arrangement that people would follow.
Why did that work? Because it wasn’t about preaching a message to people, it was demonstrating how you could practically do it. Showing people how to do something is much more powerful, according to all the research, than simply hitting them with the message that they should do it.
But then there are times when the message can be a much more negative one. For instance, the phenomenon of social media commenting has arguably created a new norm where some people have seen from common practice that it is acceptable, and perhaps even desirable, to be offensively rude to people with whom you disagree.
That becomes a much more difficult thing to manage. After all, there is a fine line between cracking down on abusive behaviour and curtailing free speech. Media companies have been struggling for some time with the reality that they have to do more than simply enforce the laws of the land – at least, if they take protecting their users seriously.
At times the constantly changing and evolving mass that is the internet seems like one gigantic chess game, with action and reaction taking place all the time.
Marketers are part of this game, with the rise of adblockers being testament to how badly they’ve sometimes done in creating the most crass layer of interruptions to people in their attempt to sell to them, so much so that large numbers are embracing technology that will keep them out.
That’s not great news for content producers, who often depend on advertising to be able to produce content that is given away for free. So now you have technology being used to block access to content by people who are using technology to block access to advertisers. One can only guess at the next counter-move.
The internet has become a very tetchy place, for sure.
But there are still opportunities for marketers to use the new media with great effect and to do so in a way that makes the most of the medium’s power to change people’s behaviours for the better.
One example, for instance, is how Aviva produced an app that you can use to check how good your driving is, and to give you information to improve. The killer feature was that families could use it to compete with each other, something that gave it the best elements of a game.
Of course, the substantial benefit of this was that Avivia would give recognition to the better drivers in terms of their insurance premiums. And, of course, training younger people to be better drivers helps to save lives.
It was a great example of how creative marketing using the new media can be highly effective without ever once looking like the sort of annoying pop-up or banner that someone would want to block.
Above, you can see a vlog I produced from my trip to the conference, and the next episode of the Respectful Business Podcast will consider one of the issues in greater depth.
You can see more about the Media CSR Forum here.
