Is action on climate possible in a democracy?
08 June 2015
A recent YouGov survey has highlighted the fact that in the US and UK there is a significant percentage of people who "do not agree to any international agreement that addresses climate change." In China, the position was quite different, with negligible numbers thinking the same. This was reported in the Independent as "UK and US main barriers to addressing climate change" which really doesn't get us to the heart of what's going on here.
For a start, because it was written up by a UK paper it didn't actually include the full story. It wasn't just the US and the UK - significant numbers of citizens in Norway, Finland and Sweden also wanted to avoid the topic.
It's worth noting that China, which delivered such great eco-conscious credentials on behalf of its citizens, is not a democracy. Free and frank political debate is not allowed. Political advertising by third parties does not happen. And the country is enduring some of the consequences of a period of environmentally-blind economic development, so the negatives of a degraded environment are very visible and close to home.
But the fact that it's not a democracy may be the most important factor.
Why do 32 percent of people in the US, and 26 percent of people in the UK, think that climate change "is not a serious problem" in spite of the scientific consensus that it is? Largely because active and vociferous publicity campaigns have been fought to sow doubt into the public mind.
This is a product of US-style democracy where it has long been believed - and practiced - that negative campaigning is the most effective type of campaigning. If you can scare voters, or incite their cynicism, about a candidate then that will be much more effective than simply campaigning in a positive way for your own. OK - maybe voters dislike it in theory. And perhaps it polarises people in a way that is unhealthy for democratic states generally. But that hasn't stopped it becoming a bigger and bigger feature of campaigning.
And that hasn't just been the case for elections - it has also been the case for certain issues and climate change is right up there. Well funded bodies with a short-term interest in the status quo have been quick to directly advertise in the US, or find other routes to publicise in the UK, misinformation specifically designed to create doubt and cynicism over the science.
That is what you can do in a democracy. The freedom of the exchange of ideas and debate is supposed to make us stronger and more resilient. Arguably, it makes robust action on climate change impossible. Negative campaigning works even if the arguments upon which its based are incorrect, so long as they are reasonably intuitive.
"Record freezing weather - so much for global warming." "Scientists play up climate change fears to get access to government grants." That kind of thing will always play well with a significant percentage of the audience.
This is a real problem because democracy remains our preferred solution - and the only viable solution - for managing our affairs. If it proves incapable of holding a consensus over something so important, that suggests we're on our way out.
I recall a conference three or four years ago where I debated one noted environmentalist whose view was that we needed a benign dictatorship to enforce green policies such as a personal carbon budget for every human being and population control. I opposed this (and still do, in case there's any doubt). His central contention was sound - in a democracy it's almost impossible to get people to vote for measures that will embrace any degree of reduction of consumption - or "quality of life." People won't vote to abolish foreign holidays, or higher prices in the shops.
This is obvious. You only have to look at the Green Party in the UK. As an environmentalist party whose central message is often about giving up things people currently take for granted (routine cheap flights, for instance), it positioned itself as 'anti-austerity' because that seemed to be the way to get votes. Of all the parties that should have supported the idea that you can't spend what you don't have, they lined up with the fantasists that said there was an easy solution to years of living on credit.
My debating opponent's proposed solution was no solution at all. If you study the history of dictatorships throughout history, they have a universal track record of failing to be benign. From a purely mechanistic viewpoint, a dictatorship will never be sustainable because the amount of resource that goes into keeping people in their place is vast, and the lack of accountability mechanisms mean that people make self-serving decisions not community-interest ones. We shouldn't even have to have that conversation.
And particularly in countries like the UK and the US. Quite a lot of us would be fighting to the death against an imposed tyranny like that.
It is very inconvenient, therefore, that China shows an alternative view. Its government dived into unsustainable development, but on realising its mistake, it has been able to act more quickly to address the problem. The huge shift in investment towards renewables in China is, for instance, calculated to mean that the country will peak on carbon emissions in 2025. And China was already famous for being the country that imposed a one-child-per-family policy - not necessarily a successful model of dealing with the problem of overpopulation, but an active experiment on the issue when the rest of the world is in denial as to whether population is part of the equation at all.
The point is it's not good enough to win more progressive action in the next election (whichever country, and whichever election that may be). If the 'other lot' simply reverse the policies when they come in, then it won't meet the criteria for long-term sustainable action. These things have to form the basis of a cross-party consensus, as unshakeable as the conviction that people should be able to get water to drink and food to eat.
There is no easy way out of this. Every measure you could take to improve the situation has big negatives. Supposing we simply banned climate change denial. Tried to make it as unacceptable in public as denying that the holocaust took place. As soon as you get to the point where governments actively suppress the expression of political opinion - however apparently undesirable - where does that stop? The only difference between a government that restricts the right to cast doubt on climate change, and one that restricts the right to claim climate change is a problem is the point of view of those taking the decisions. Both would claim (however outrageously) to have the backing of science, or God, or whatever authority is held to matter the most. Freedom of speech is the only system that allows accountability to be built in.
Freedom of speech also provides the avenue whereby vested interests can attack public opinion to cast doubt and erode the support for any kind of sustained political will.
What does this mean for the socially responsible business community?
1. Take an interest in the health of public policy debate. As non-ideological bodies whose future success depends on a sober reflection on what the science tells us, businesses are in the best position to provide leadership where political bodies fail us.
2. Make sure you don't line up on the side of the anti-science vested interests. At least avoid being part of the problem. Not too much to ask, surely.
3. Lead by example. Show that you can create wealth successfully in a more sustainable way. Create disruptive innovation in energy markets. Come up with new business models. And hammer politicians hard if they put barriers up to make this possible.
In other words, don't wait for settled political will. Don't wait for the debate to be conclusively won. Don't wait for all of your peers to agree. And be prepared to make a few enemies if you really have to. Because some things are genuinely worth fighting for. Freedom of speech is one. So is sustainability. To get both is going to need more than words - it's going to need practical action that demonstrates solutions that people will vote for, whether with their wallets or at the ballot box.
