How sustainability is the quiet partner in CEO Steve Easterbrook’s turnaround of McDonald’s
09 May 2016
When Steve Easterbrook was flown in from Britain to take the helm of McDonald’s just a year ago, the company was in big trouble. It had been flat-lining for some time, and analysts were on the verge of writing it off as a company in terminal decline.
If you were interested in corporate sustainability, there were reasons for some optimism with the appointment. Easterbrook, while turning around McDonald’s in the UK, had shown interest in a number of sustainability issues. He had been one of the senior business champions for the Prince of Wales’ Rainforest Project, and had led a “seeing is believing” visit, taking other executives to visit projects providing learning support to young people at risk.
And, of course, within the restaurant itself, there were signs in how the company went about its core business. It announced that it was only to serve Rainforest Alliance certified coffee and also said it would sell MSC certified fish.
Another of the changes he initiated was the experimentation with healthier menu options, in response to growing concerns about the impact of fast food meals. Not all of those experiments were necessarily a success (at that point, going to McDonald’s for a salad was just too off-brand for some people) but it showed a willingness to adapt the model to fit modern tastes and expectations.
His value in that area was acknowledged by the company the year before he nabbed the top job. As well as being chief brand officer, his role was expanded in 2014 to include responsibility for corporate strategy, corporate responsibility, sustainability and philanthropy.
The fact that his mantra when he became CEO was that McDonald’s needed to be a “modern, progressive burger company” also played on that perception. It was trendy competitors with good environmental credentials like Chipotle that had been attracting customers away. So clearly ‘progressive’ was going to mean change in that direction.
But first and foremost he was coming in with a huge expectation on his shoulders that he would turn around the company’s financial performance. Sustainability initiatives would quickly lose support if that didn’t happen.
And first signs were not good. The company took a risk by introducing an all-day breakfast to the menu. Franchisees were unhappy because it made their lives more difficult. Analysts mocked the move, and described him as floundering in the job. A video the company produced with him talking about the turnaround plan was widely derided. It was a developing narrative that could easily have taken hold and seen him out within the year.
Except that the plan started to work. Having become notorious for being slow-moving and bureaucratic, under Easterbrook McDonald’s actually executed on the all-day breakfast initiative in just four months, and the figures quickly began to show that the gamble was paying off. The last quarter of 2015 saw sales jump 5.7%, the first such increase for a very long time.
In addition, the company started giving detailed attention to a lot of different things. How people were trained. It raised the pay rates for employees for restaurants it directly controlled. It simplified menus. Even down to the font used for signs – everything was given a careful review.
But also, it began making step-by-step moves on the sustainability agenda.
It announced that it was to reduce the use of antibiotics in its chicken products, particularly those that can have an impact on human health. It made a pledge to use only cage-free eggs in the US and Canada – a huge undertaking for a company that uses 2.1 billion eggs per year. And that’s before you factor in the impact of the all-day breakfast, the main hero for which is the Egg McMuffin.
The third initiative was that it would not contribute to deforestation in areas most critical to reducing carbon in the atmosphere.
Most recently it has said that its chicken nuggets will be made to a new recipe that will have no artificial preservatives.
The company has committed to start purchasing a portion of its beef from verified sustainable sources. What’s interesting is that this isn’t to go to a niche menu offer, a “sustainable beef burger”. It will simply be quietly blended into the company’s main mix for its core products, with the percentage sourced sustainably increasing over time.
This is a sign that this isn’t a play for an “ethical consumer”, or an attempt to build eco-messaging into the overall brand. Although some campaigners might welcome such a move, it’s doubtful it would really play that well with the company’s mainstream customers.
But it is a sign that the company is just putting the pieces into place behind the scenes so that those core products that will drive its future success in the marketplace will have a more positive impact. Because of the company’s massive scale, you should never underestimate how hard some of these moves are.
One time the company decided to add a blueberry product to its menu, the company overnight needed to buy one third of all the blueberries produced in the US. That’s the kind of scale we’re talking about.
At the moment, there are no signs that Easterbrook is making moves to become a more public face for sustainability, in the way that execs such as Paul Polman at Unilever and Richard Branson have done. He’s been content to push the changes through the machinery, let the McDonald’s team work together, and to represent their work as part of the whole.
There’s no doubt that some caution is definitely called for. It is still early days for the McDonald’s recovery, and it needs to be seen as having some real lasting momentum before the company provides the solidity of a platform to take even further steps.
But even if it’s a quiet revolution, there’s no doubt that McDonald’s is more seriously engaging with its impact. Under Steve Easterbrook, it is experimenting with what is possible, and is willing to make some bold step changes.
It will be worth watching to see how the experiment plays out.
